The health and economic crises unleashed by the spread of the Covid-19 have demanded extraordinary measures by governments and political leaders.
In democratic countries, government and opposition leaders, to different extents, team up and work together to address any major crisis, including to enact laws and policies to deal with it.
In extraordinary circumstances, the reasons for working as a team are many, and so are the benefits.
In a crisis there is one goal – to beat the enemy. Some of the country’s best minds are pulling together, rather than sitting on opposite sides and pulling in different directions.
Working together not only ensures best outcomes, but it also gives hope and encouragement to the electorate who witness their politicians leading by example.
At times of crisis, we need to band together, not to bicker.
However in democratic countries, there is also recognition that even in extraordinary times, accountability and transparency in the conduct of government are paramount in giving confidence to the people.
Some countries have put both the opposition and government together to discuss and agree on funding packages.
In New Zealand, the Leader of the Opposition is the chair of the committee which oversees and holds government to account on how it is dealing with the crisis.
It is a fine example of a country recognising the importance of accountability, not to mention the Opposition’s important role, and the benefit to the nation as a whole.
Benjamin Disraeli was a British party leader who served more than once in the roles of Prime Minister and Leader of the Opposition. He once said that “no government can long be secure without a formidable opposition”.
This indicates very aptly why the role of opposition, especially in a democracy, is important. Arguably it is even more important in extraordinary circumstances, such as those we face today.
The uncertainty about COVID-19 and its impact on our economies makes it even more important that governments do the right thing in terms of their policies.
This crisis has already been a turning point for many countries. It has imposed new imperatives for policies, governance and accountability to ensure that scarce resources are used in a transparent and efficient way to minimise the damage on people’s quality of life.
We must now focus on the next phase – life after Covid-19. Mistakes here may be hard to correct.
For instance, we can no longer withstand any wastage or extravagance in Government spending.
It has cost us dearly before. In a time of crisis, sudden and high expenditure becomes necessary – in this crisis, for example, on health measures and economic relief packages.
The purse strings are loosened because spending is urgent.
But this is also where abuses can occur. That is why scrutiny of government policies at this extraordinary time is even more important.
All of us are accepting that in the current crisis there will be some restrictions on our rights and freedoms caused by lockdowns and curfews.
However, in less democratic countries, governments are using the situation for repressive measures purely to silence their critics and opponents.
In Fiji, we have already seen excessive use of power to enforce measures supposedly connected to the pandemic. This includes not just the arrest and excessive detention of citizens accused of breaching curfews and lockdowns (where the police have now always acted with common sense or compassion).
It also extends to detaining opposition politicians such as Opposition Whip Lynda Tabuya and National Federation Party president Pio Tikoduadua.
I do not comment here on the charges against Ms Tabuya. But there was no need for the police to detain her in a cell for more than 48 hours after her arrest. This behaviour, repeated many times in the last few weeks, suggests that the police want to inflict their own punishment on people they believe to have broken laws.
It is not the police’s job to punish people. Their job is to investigate possible crimes and detain people if they are a risk to others or to justice.
They must bring accused people to a court. It is for the court to decide if they are innocent or guilty and to decide on the punishment.
Recently, in a pro-government newspaper, a senior Fiji military officer actually suggested that COVID-19 is a good enough reason to restrict freedom of expression and the media. This is a dangerous proposition – but on past history, is anyone surprised?
We have already seen generally over the years that media independence is becoming compromised, especially for critics of governments, in other Pacific Island countries. In a democracy the role of the opposition is to hold government to account, including when governments attempt to suppress freedom of speech or the rights of the media.
So opposition parties in the Pacific must take a more active role in doing so. Sometimes, they may prefer to be quiet about these things, because they would like to behave in the same way if they take power.
However, that attitude is short-sighted and self-defeating and it is not in the interests of the people they say they are serving.
This means that opposition parties have to become more vigilant, more vocal and more articulate on some of these fundamental issues.
Only then we can ensure that whoever is in government, they will respect these universal values of liberty, democracy and media freedom in the Pacific.
Perhaps, given some of the trends in our region, it is time to have a Pacific Islands Opposition Party Leaders Forum so that there is a collective regional voice to hold governments to account on fundamental issues such as human rights, media freedom, climate change, economic integration and regional public goods.
- Prof Biman Prasad is the leader of the National Federation Party. This is an edited version of an article he wrote for the “Pacific Outlook” blog of Griffith University in Australia. The views expressed in this article are not necessarily those of The Fiji Times.


