What kind of GCC for Fiji? – Time for ‘bystanders’ to speak up

Listen to this article:

The GCC complex in Nasese, Suva before it burned down. Picture: FILE

In Letters to the Editor (Feb 18, 2023) The Fiji Times regular correspondent Dr Christopher Griffin (my old USP colleague) makes a number of cogent points from Perth in response to Shamima Ali’s call for politicians to stop getting political mileage Fiji’s crisis of violence against women and children.

He challenges a Fiji rightly rejoicing at the removal of an oppressive government: “As well as pointing the finger we should be asking what was I doing when I knew so much was wrong; with the hospitals, schools, media, police, churches, etc. Was I just a bystander?”

Dr Griffin himself has written many pointed letters over the years.

But I would like to suggest that readers of today’s The Fiji Times can go over issues of The Fiji Times to note the many times that The Fiji Times opinion writers raised matters of serious public concern, even during the severe censorship years after the 2006 coup when The Fiji Times journalists and publishers were facing the danger of prison terms.

One old important issue has been resuscitated by the Coalition Government’s decision in 2023 to reinstate the Great Council of Chiefs, which the Bainimarama Government claimed to dissolve in 2012.

In The Fiji Times of February 18, 2023, respected lawyer Graham Leung wrote an excellent balanced historical piece concluding that a “reformed GCC should be above partisan party politics and be nonaligned”.

While I agree with him that it is not for non-indigenous Fijians to decide what the GCC should be in function and form, this economist has previously (in 2007 and 2015) raised a number of issues through the pages of The Fiji Times when the GCC was allegedly being shut down.

These issues are just as relevant today now that the Coalition Government is planning to reinstate the GCC.

The QVSOB panel

Just after the 2006 coup, The Fiji Times bravely published (July 28, 2007) my article “Wake up call for GCC” which was based on a presentation at a panel discussion organised by the QVSOB Association and the University of the South Pacific.

This was a presentation that I had prepared for the GCC at the request of the late Ratu Ovini Bokini (chair of GCC) who wanted that august body to better understand how global forces were affecting Fiji and indigenous Fijians in particular.

Unfortunately, the 2006 coup happened and the GCC was suspended. While I respect Graham Leong’s view that only indigenous Fijians should decide what the GCC should be, I pointed out in that 2007 article why all Fiji citizens needed to be involved in the GCC question.

This is what I said back then: “Firstly, the future of all citizens of Fiji is deeply affected by the role that the GCC plays, or does not play. The GCC appoints the President of Fiji, and must endorse the Vice Presidents.

The incumbents of these positions (and the GCC) have been critical in determining the kinds of political outcome we have had in 1987, 2000 and 2006. There could have been worse outcomes; and better.

“The GCC’s nominees to Senate have the final say on any legislation affecting Fijian resources and issues. The GCC is the national coordinator of the traditional Fijian leadership of the provinces. The GCC is the only national non-political institution that is expected to provide leadership on all matters critical to the Fijian people and to Fiji. The GCC is in some ways, perhaps a superior alternative to political parties which have their own agenda which come and go”.

I suggested to the audience (mostly QVS and other indigenous Fijian social leaders) that the illegal GCC suspension by the Bainimarama Government should not be taken as a “winding-up order” but a belated “wake-up call” and to think about how the GCC need to be reformed and in what areas. I asked the audience to give their own personal assessment according to 10 criteria which I thought important as an economist.

I clearly hoped for public discussion and debate, at least among the indigenous Fijians.

No public discussion took place

The fact that public discussion did not take place in the face of the brutal Bainimarama Government crackdown on public dissension with their policies meant that the public became the “bystanders” that Dr Griffin criticised last Saturday.

So eight years later, I wrote another opinion published by The Fiji Times (March 21, 2015). This article makes clear that The Fiji Times has not been a bystander in the great issues concerning Fiji’s development, but an active supporter of public debate and discussion, unlike the other print media in Fiji (who shall remain unnamed).

I sincerely hope that The Fiji Times readers today take up the challenge and not just be “bystanders” in the reinstatement of the GCC.

The “key words” which accompany every article in my latest volume of these articles (and go into the index), give you a great idea of the contents of the article. They are: “culture of silence”, “FAB”, “Fijian leadership”, “globalisation”, “Great Council of Chiefs”, “NLTB”, “qualified commoners”, “QVSOB”, “Radike Qereqeretabua”, “Ratu Ovini Bokini”, “Ratu Sir Kamisese Mara”, “Ratu Sir Lala Sukuna” and “Savenaca Siwatibau”.

In that article I said: “In 2007, the QVSOB Association and USP organised a panel discussion of which I was a part, titled Challenges Facing Fijian Leadership. I focussed on the performance of the Great Council of Chiefs (GCC) which had just been suspended by the Bainimarama Government and which, he declares today, is not ever going to be ever resuscitated.

“I do not address Bainimarama’s motives in getting rid of a colonial institution designed to control Fijians through their chiefs, nor do I address his dictatorial method of doing so. I simply examine the performance of the GCC (and chiefs in general) according to criteria I, as an economist, feel are important “bread and butter” issues for ordinary Fijians in today’s world.

“In the discussions and debate, the Fiji public must differentiate between the chiefly system for which ordinary Fijians still have a great respect in their day to day communal lives, and the GCC itself, as a national body which used to have a crucial formal role in Fiji’s politics.

“In that 2007 panel discussion, I asked the audience to judge the performance of the GCC by ten criteria, which we can also use to judge chiefs in general. Of course, some individual chiefs (like Ro Temumu Kepa, Ratu Joni Madraiwiwi, Ratu Jone Dakuvula, Ratu Ropate Qalo, Adi Eci Nabalarua) will come out with flying colours on their own personal merits and achievements (and some do not even use their titles).”

The Chiefs’ exam

In 2007, I had asked the audience to assess the performance of the GCC (or chiefs in general) in providing leadership to ordinary indigenous Fijians, with a score of “0” (total failure), “5” (average) and “10” (excellent) My personal (and perhaps “kind”) assessments out of a top possible score of 10, are in brackets (you the readers can give your own score and add to the criteria).

(1) The GCC as the “glue” that has helped maintain the unity and strength of the Fijian vanua – (8) (2) Did the GCC provide sound guidance to provinces, villages and ordinary Fijians on economic development strategies compatible with the new World Trade Organisation (WTO) world order?

Have they initiated sound industries, enterprises, employment creating opportunities, savings and investment schemes? –

(1) (3) For example, has the GCC assisted Fijians to earn remittance earnings (as security guards, nurses, care-givers, seasonal labour schemes) which have become the largest foreign exchange earner, injecting more funds into the rural areas than banks? –

(1) (4) How efficiently has the GCC managed (through the NLTB and FAB) Fijian resources (land, timber, sea) in the resource owners’ own interests, including the provision of secure long-term commercial leases to the land-owners themselves? –

(2) (5) How efficiently has the GCC helped (through the NLTB and FAB) to manage Fijian resources in the national interest? –

(5) (6) Has the GCC provided solid clear guidance to Fijian families on a better balance between family interests and traditional obligations (reguregu, weddings, solis), or are families making these difficult choices entirely on their own? –

(0) (7) Has the GCC given clear principled consistent guidance to Fijians at times of political crises (1987, 2000, 2006)? –

(0) (8) Are the GCC leaders known for transparent, principled, peaceful and timely resolution of succession to chiefly titles? Or have numerous disputes continued to paralyse decisionmaking and created social discontent and political instability amongst Fijians? eg the Vunivalu title?) –

(2) (9) Have the GCC leaders acquired the qualifications, skills and experience (economic, financial, legal, technical, professional) needed to guide ordinary Fijians in the globalised 21st century or even succeed on their own merits in the private sector? –

(1) (10) Given that the qualifications/skills/ experience required by question 9 are not hereditary, has the GCC attempted to coopt qualified commoner Fijians into the GCC (like the British House of Lords) and recognize them formally as good Fijian leaders? –

(1) My “kind” assessment adds up to 21 out of 100, a complete failure (and 11 out of 100 if we give them (-10) for all the damage they did in the coups of 1987 and 2000). Even if we were to be kinder on several of these criteria, you would still not reach 50 out of 100.

One can disagree with Bainimarama on the dictatorial process by which he has dismantled the GCC, but on the objective criteria above, the GCC in 2007 was badly failing the exam.

Years later, the chiefs still have not risen to the challenge and are still badly failing. Note that there has been nothing to stop the chiefs of Fiji from getting together informally, or even formally, to replace the GCC and address their common interests.

In 2007, I had suggested (The Fiji Times, July 28, 2007) that the GCC should take their suspension as a “wake up call”, not a “winding down” order.

They have still not woken up. On the contrary, some high chiefs joined Bainimarama and used their titles to help implement his coup, despite Bainimarama’s dismantling their highest body.

Today, despite the national leadership provided by individual chiefs (like Ro Temumu Kepa and Ratu Naiqama Lalabalavu), the fact is that as a group, the GCC quietly went out of sight. What does that say about the degree of their commitment and relevance to indigenous Fijian leadership?

Why no popular protests?

Just as interesting is that there has been no popular protest from ordinary indigenous Fijians – and certainly not from the educated and qualified ones – among them about the suspension of the GCC.

Today there is no shortage of qualified skilled indigenous Fijians (mostly commoners but also some chiefs), men and women, who prove themselves on a daily basis as leaders in a wide variety of fields: as entrepreneurs, corporate managers, academics, educationists, lawyers, doctors, NGO leaders, scientists, engineers, architects (I won’t draw up a list in case I offend those left out).

The fact that they say nothing publicly about the closing down of the GCC, should make SODELPA think very hard about making the GCC a central issue for their campaign in Parliament, especially when there are other far more important issues.

It is comical that one SODELPA MP claimed that the chiefs’ authority derives from God, but then the same person also prophesied that Fiji would be devastated by an earthquake and tsunami on July 23, 2010.

This was not particularly helpful to the tourism industry, especially coming from a top tourism executive responsible for marketing Fiji.

What progress?

In my 2007 article I had suggested a five-point agenda for a review of the GCC and the role of the chiefs:

• the development of a sound development strategy for indigenous Fijians for the globalised world order;

• reform of the system of allocating iTaukei lease monies;

• to resolve speedily the conflicts over chiefly titles;

• to remove the differentiation of dividend rates between Class A and Class B shareholders in Fijian Holdings Ltd; and

• to co-opt qualified commoner Fijians into Fijian leadership. Readers might want to ask how many of these were achieved by the Bainimarama Government, whatever else they did or did not do.

• PROFESSOR WADAN NARSEY is (as he was in 2011) a leading Pacific economist and commentator on public affairs in Fiji. The views in this article are not necessarily the views of The Fiji Times.