Magistrate exceeded jurisdiction in imposing $10,000 fine – High Court

Listen to this article:

The High Court in Suva has ruled that a magistrate exceeded his jurisdiction by imposing a $10,000 fine on a man who pleaded guilty to dangerous driving occasioning grievous harm and failing to comply with requirements following an accident.

However, High Court judge Justice Thusara Rajasinghe has retained the non-conviction recorded against Tavinesh Akshay Naicker, taking into consideration the compensation already paid to the victim.

The State had appealed against the sentence handed down on October 27, 2025, arguing that the magistrate had erred in law and fact by imposing a $10,000 fine and recording a non-conviction.

Naicker had pleaded guilty to both charges and paid the $10,000 in several instalments as compensation to the victim for pain and suffering.

Justice Rajasinghe said the maximum fine prescribed for dangerous driving occasioning grievous harm was $2,000, while the maximum fine for failing to comply with requirements following an accident was $200.

He ruled that the magistrate had no jurisdiction to impose a $10,000 fine and subsequently order that it be paid as compensation.

“Therefore, imposing a $10,000 fine and then ordering the Respondent to pay it as compensation to the victim under Section 153 of the Criminal Procedure Act was beyond the Learned Magistrate’s jurisdiction,” Justice Rajasinghe said.

However, he noted that Naicker had already paid the victim the full amount and that reversing the compensation order would create difficulties for the victim.

“It would be impractical and would surely place the victim in a difficult position if the Court set aside the said order of compensation and required the victim to return $10,000.”

Justice Rajasinghe also noted that the magistrate had relied heavily on the compensation paid and a subsequent letter from the victim expressing forgiveness and requesting that a non-conviction be recorded.

“Had there been no such payment of compensation, the victim would most likely not have given such a letter,” he said.

“Hence, it appears that the $10,000 payment significantly contributed to the entry of a non-conviction.”

The court heard that Naicker had filed an affidavit during the appeal proceedings confirming that he remained willing to pay the victim $10,000 even if the original compensation order was found to be incorrect.

Justice Rajasinghe declined to make an adverse finding on the recording of a non-conviction, citing the particular circumstances of the case and the practical difficulties of reversing the original outcome.

However, he strongly cautioned against applying the decision generally in other cases involving non-convictions.

“I emphasize, in the strongest terms, that this decision is not for general application to the issue of entering a non-conviction and is relevant only to the specific factual situation in this matter.”

Justice Rajasinghe allowed the State’s appeal, set aside the original sentence and imposed a $2,000 fine for both offences, directing that the money be paid to the victim as compensation.

Taking into account the remaining $8,000 as further compensation, he recorded a non-conviction against Naicker under Section 15(f) of the Sentencing and Penalties Act.

The court deemed the $10,000 already paid by Naicker as compliance with the revised sentence.

The judgment was delivered on November 13, with 30 days allowed to appeal to the Fiji Court of Appeal.