The unanimous judgment was delivered on October 29 by Supreme Court President Justice Salesi Temo, Justice Terence Arnold and Justice Geoffrey Nettle.
The man was convicted by the High Court in Lautoka on May 18, 2018, of one count of rape and one count of criminal intimidation involving his teenage stepdaughter.
He was sentenced to 15 years’ imprisonment with a non-parole period of 12 years.
His previous attempts to appeal against his conviction were unsuccessful in December 2020 and May 2024.
In its judgment, the Supreme Court found that a medical report prepared following an examination of the complainant contained significant discrepancies concerning the date of the alleged offence and aspects of her testimony.
Although the prosecution had disclosed the medical report to the defence before the trial, it decided not to tender it as evidence.
Writing the judgment, Justice Nettle said the Court of Appeal had incorrectly focused on the competence of the defence counsel rather than the responsibilities of the prosecution.
“Generally speaking, a prosecutor is bound to call or tender all available relevant, probative and credible evidence regardless of whether it advances or detracts from the prosecution case,” he said.
Justice Nettle said it was not sufficient to argue that the defence counsel could have tendered the medical report.
The Supreme Court noted that the State had failed to provide an explanation as to why the prosecution decided not to tender the report.
The State, in an affidavit, said the doctor who prepared the report could not be contacted at the time of the trial.
However, the court questioned why the doctor, who was reportedly stationed at the hospital in Suva, could not have been summoned to appear.
Justice Nettle said that if the decision not to tender the report had been made for tactical reasons to avoid weakening the prosecution’s case, it would have been improper.
The court found that the medical report contained information that could have raised questions about the reliability of the evidence presented at trial.
“Viewed therefore against the conduct of the trial taken as a whole, it can be seen that the prosecutor’s failure to tender the report denied the petitioner a chance of diminishing the strength of the prosecution case and so denied him a chance of acquittal to which he was justly entitled,” Justice Nettle said.
“That was a miscarriage of justice.”
The Supreme Court said it could not be satisfied that the man would inevitably have been convicted had the medical report been presented at trial.
It subsequently granted special leave to appeal, allowed the appeal, quashed both convictions and set aside the sentence.
While ordering a retrial, the Supreme Court said the State would need to consider whether proceeding with another trial was appropriate.
“The State will need to consider, however, whether, in view of the time since the alleged events and the time the petitioner has already spent in custody, it is appropriate that he be put up for trial again.”
The decision to quash the convictions does not amount to an acquittal, with the Supreme Court expressly ordering a new trial.


