High cost of smoking

Listen to this article:

Picture: FILE

The recently released report “The case for scaling-up World Health Organization Framework Convention on Tobacco Control Implementation in Fiji” has some startling data and recommendations on how to control tobacco use in Fiji. It states more than 1200 Fijians die every year from tobacco-related illnesses, accounting for nearly 17 per cent of all deaths in the country. Tobacco costs Fiji $319 million every year, investing now in five proven tobacco control measures will prevent more than 5400 deaths and avert $900m in health costs and economic losses by 2035.

The report states that in 2019, tobacco use caused $319m in economic losses. These losses are equivalent to 2.7 per cent of Fiji’s GDP and are about 4.3 times more than the revenue generated by cigarette taxes. The losses include $11.5m in healthcare expenditures, and $307m in indirect losses due to tobacco-attributable mortality and ill-health as well as workplace smoking breaks. The indirect economic losses from current tobacco use in Fiji — 96 per cent of all tobacco-related costs — indicate that tobacco use impedes development in Fiji beyond health.

The burden of tobacco use

The report states that in 2019, tobacco use caused an estimated 1271 deaths in Fiji, 71 per cent of which occurred among those under 70 years. These deaths amount to 21,134 years of life lost, which are lost productive years in which many of those individuals would have contributed to the workforce. The economic losses in 2019 due to tobacco-related mortality are estimated at $229m. While the costs of mortality are high, the consequences of tobacco use begin long before death. “As individuals suffer from tobacco-attributable diseases (e.g., cardiovascular diseases, respiratory conditions, cancers), expensive medical care is required to treat them,” states the report. Spending on medical treatment for illnesses caused by smoking cost the Government $8m in 2019 and caused Fijian citizens to spend $1.6m in out-of-pocket healthcare expenditures. “Private insurance and non-profit institutions serving households spent $1.8m on treating tobacco-attributable diseases in 2019. In total, healthcare expenditures attributable to smoking amounted $11.5m. The report states that in addition to healthcare costs, as individuals become sick, they are more likely to miss days of work (absenteeism) or to be less productive at work (presenteeism). “In 2019, the cost of excess absenteeism due to tobacco-related illness was $14m and the cost of presenteeism due to cigarette smoking was $38m. The report states that even in their healthy years, workers who smoke are more likely to incur productivity loss than workers who do not smoke. “Smokers take an estimated 10 additional minutes per day in breaks than non-smoking employees. If 10 minutes of time is valued at the average worker’s salary, the compounding impact of 85,224 employed smokers taking 10 minutes per day for smoke breaks is equivalent to losing $27m in productive output annually.” In total, tobacco use cost Fiji’s economy $319m in 2019, states the report.

Steps to control tobacco use

1. Increase tobacco taxation to reduce the affordability of tobacco products:

The report states that in Fiji, taxes account for 42.1 per cent of the retail price of the most sold cigarette brand, of which 33.8 per cent is the excise tax share. Fiji applies a three-tier specific excise tax regime on cigarettes based on whether the final product contains locally grown tobacco, imported tobacco or a combination of the two. “Suki, a native form of tobacco, is not taxed. There is substantial scope to reach what is considered in the WHO Report on the Global Tobacco Epidemic as the highest level of achievement, which is for total taxes to represent at least 75 per cent of the retail price,” states the report. Additionally, there could be uniform specific taxes, for tax rates to be monitored, increased and adjusted on a regular basis, potentially annually, taking into account inflation and income growth. “The investment case examines the impact of raising cigarette taxes to levels considered as the highest level of achievement. “Beginning in 2023, the specific excise tax is raised an average of 1 Fijian dollar per year until 2028, with continued gradual increases of FJD 0.65 through 2035. Increasing tobacco taxes to at least 75 per cent of the retail price will decrease tobacco use and generate additional revenue for the Government that can be reinvested in tobacco control, universal health coverage and development,” states the report. Increasing tobacco taxes will particularly benefit the poor who are more sensitive to price changes and therefore more likely to reduce their consumption or quit, states the report.

2. Create smoke-free public and workplaces to protect people from the harms of tobacco smoke:

The report states Fiji has completely banned smoking in several types of indoor spaces (e.g., healthcare and educational facilities, restaurants, indoor stadiums/arenas). However, designated smoking areas are allowed in bars and nightclubs. “In addition, exceptions apply in government facilities, indoor workplaces, private offices and cultural facilities. There are also concerns related to compliance with the existing smoking bans,” states the report. Implementing a complete ban on smoking in all public places, and strengthening enforcement, would further reduce exposure to second-hand smoke and provide social and economic benefits.

3. Implement plain packaging of tobacco product:

There are currently no laws or other forms of regulations that mandate plain packaging of tobacco products.

4. Enact and enforce a comprehensive ban on all forms of tobacco advertising, promotion and sponsorship:

Most forms of domestic advertising are banned (e.g. tv, radio, print, billboards). However, other forms such as point of sale display as well as international TV, radio, internet and print media are restricted but not banned. In addition, tobacco companies can engage in some forms of sponsorship.

5. Promote cessation of tobacco use and treatment for tobacco dependence _ Offer brief advice to quit at the primary care level:

Cost-covered cessation support is currently offered in some hospitals and health clinics. There is no national toll-free quit line and pharmacological interventions are available though cost is not covered by the national health insurance scheme.

Health benefits – lives saved

The full implementation of the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (WHO FCTC) would lower the prevalence of tobacco use, leading to substantial health gains now and into the future, the report states. Specifically, implementing the package of five WHO FCTC policy actions that are the focus of this investment case would reduce the prevalence of cigarette smoking by 47 per cent (in relative terms) over 15 years, saving 5,411 lives from 2021-2035, or 361 lives annually. “Implementing the tobacco control policy package would result in Fiji avoiding 26 per cent of the economic loss that it is expected to incur from tobacco use over the next 15 years. In total, over 15 years Fiji would save about $900m that would otherwise be lost if the package of five key WHO FCTC policy actions were not implemented,” states the report. This is equivalent to around $60m in annual avoided losses. With better health that would arise from implementation of the WHO FCTC, fewer individuals would need access to healthcare services due to tobacco-related diseases, resulting in direct cost savings to the government and citizens. Better health also leads to increased productivity. “Fewer working-age individuals leave the workforce prematurely due to death, illness or disability. Workers miss fewer days of work (absenteeism) and are less hindered by health complications while at work (presenteeism). Finally, because the prevalence of smoking declines, fewer smoke breaks are taken in the workplace.”