Supreme Court upholds Isoof’s five murder convictions

Listen to this article:

Muhammed Raheesh Isoof appeared at the Lautoka High Court Picture: REINAL CHAND/FILE

The Supreme Court of Fiji has unanimously dismissed the appeal of Muhammed Raheesh Isoof, upholding his convictions for the August 2019 murders of five family members and the attempted murder of an infant in the Nausori Highlands.

Delivering the judgment, Justice William Young, with the concurrence of Supreme Court President Justice Salesi Temo and Justice Terence Arnold, dismissed Isoof’s petition following a hearing.

Isoof was originally convicted on five counts of murder and one count of attempted murder after taking victims Nirmal Kumar, 61, his wife Usha Devi, 54, their daughter Nileshni Kajal, 35, and two granddaughters, Sanah Singh, 11, and Samara Singh, 9, to a remote location under the guise of a ritual on August 25, 2019.

The victims died from acute pesticide poisoning, while an 11-month-old infant, Samaira, was found alive next to the bodies the following day.

While granting leave to appeal to address significant hearsay and res gestae arguments surrounding witness testimony, the Supreme Court found the circumstantial evidence against Isoof overwhelming.

The Court highlighted his suspicious actions and false statements following the disappearance, the discovery of a victim’s mobile phone in his vehicle, and the lack of any credible alternative explanation for his movements.

The Court also firmly dismissed late-submitted affidavits by a third party claiming a conspiracy, labelling them as “fantastical nonsense”.