AUCKLAND, 21 APRIL 2021 (STUFF NZ)—The Moana Pasifika franchise that has been given a “conditional” licence to take part in Super Rugby has revealed key details about the eligibility rules governing its squad.
Speaking on Sky’s The Breakdown show on Monday evening, Moana Pasifika general manager Kevin Senio said that 80 per cent of the Moana Pasifika squad would either be already playing for a Pacific Islands nations such as Samoa or Tonga, or on that pathway.
That would invariably strengthen the test squad of the Pacific Island nations, but it also means that eight players out of their squad of 38 will be available for the All Blacks, Australia, or any other test nation.
“What we’ve done is use the New Zealand model and flicked it on its head,” Senio said.
“Eighty per cent of the team will have to be eligible and/or have played for Samoa, Tonga or Fiji.
“For those [80 per cent] who are going to aligning themselves into Moana Pasifika, you can’t play for the All Blacks or Australia.”
Earlier this week, Pacific Rugby Welfare CEO Daniel Leo also expressed his fear that Moana Pasifika would become “become NZs 6th Super Team”, asking World Rugby – which is providing funding to the side – to make sure that didn’t happen.
Former Wallaby Morgan Turinui also wrote last week that he feared Moana Pasifika would turn out to be “another NZ franchise who will funnel players through to the All Blacks”.
Yet, Moana Pasifika’s eligiblity mix is a complex subject, with Sky commentator Ken Laban arguing passionately on The Breakdown that All Blacks-eligible players such as Ofa Tuungafasi, Karl Tu’inukuafe, Vaea Fifita and Asafo Aumua – who aren’t starting at the Blues or Hurricanes – should be shifted into the Moana Pasifika side.
Theoretically, the 80-20 split revealed by Senio would allow a limited number of current or former All Blacks to make the shift, and also enable players such as All Black Ardie Savea – who is coming off contract – to play for Moana Pasifika.
However, Laban felt that structure wasn’t enough for Moana Pasifika to be successful, effectively accusing NZ Rugby of ‘hiding’ talent from the side.
“I don’t want to be negative, that’s certainly not my intention,” Laban said.
“But I just wonder if our game has got the backbone or the stomach to see this through.
“We saw with the Western Force, they lasted 10 years and then they were tossed out.
“I was in Japan in 2016 when the Sunwolves played their first game,…there was huge support [but they lasted five years and won nine games.
“I look at the restrictions that have been placed on this Moana Pasifika team. But they are not going to be successful if everyone hides all the players.”
But Sir John Kirwan countered that argument, insisting that selecting All Blacks-qualified players for Moana Pasifika would do little to help test rugby in the Pacific Islands.
“If you pick them is that going to help Samoa and Tonga at the next World Cup?” he asked.
Senio also said the Moana Pasifika players would be the same pay scale as the other Super Rugby sides in New Zealand, and that search for a coaching team was well under way.
“There are a number of candidates who are probably quite obvious who are out there in the market and who have expressed interest,” he said.
“We are just trying to work through that with a committee and a panel once we have shortlisted those names.
“In terms of players, that’s the discussion we’re having now with agents, and also the nationals unions such as Samoa and Tonga
“This team needs to be competitive, so it’s a balance of having established players and those who are overseas that can help this team in terms of performance.
“The other part is …to connect into the high-performance environments up in Tonga and Samoa and look at their existing programs.
“In terms of identifying talent, that’s who we are going to connect into.”
Senio also confirmed Moana Pasifika would play some homes games in Apria but primarily be based in south Auckland, potentially stepping on the Blues’ toes as they could well be in the market for the same New Zealand-born players with dual eligibility.
All Blacks great Sir Michael Jones told Stuff last week that Moana Pasifika’s conditional licence was a “groundbreaking moment” for Pasifika rugby but indicated that young players of Pasifika heritage would not necessarily have to give up their ambitions of playing for the All Blacks if they signed for Moana Pasifika.
“I’ve always been clear in my mind the power of the All Blacks dream is such that for those of us particularly born in New Zealand, we are always going to pursue that dream. I don’t think that will ever change,” he said.
“But this does allow those who are of Pacific descent who might have been born there, or might have grown up there, or might see an opportunity to represent their parents – and we’ve heard that kind of rhetoric in the past from some of the boys – to potentially represent Moana Pasifika.
”It doesn’t mean if you put your colours to Moana Pasifika that you can’t necessarily still pursue the All Blacks dream. We might also get a couple of the old boys coming back, like Steven Luatua, or you could get Ma’a Nonu wanting to put on the colours in his final year, and I think we’ve got to allow for that because it is a franchise.”


