Sitting here in Melbourne doing mundane academic work, I could not believe my eyes to read the advice given by the Honourable Aiyaz Sayed-Khaiyum to the dozens of people arrested in Ra on suspicion of plotting sedition (Fiji TV, August 20, 2015).
The report was repeated in the Fiji Sun on August 21, 2015 (from which I shall quote).
Khaiyum against
political instability
Acting Prime Minister Aiyaz Sayed-Khaiyum reminded Fiji quite correctly that: “Any form of instability can hinder economic development … overseas investors and even local investors … if they see something illegal that could happen or could be an interruption to the legal framework, they will hold back on investment, they will hold back on trying to create jobs …. rebellious activities will not help our country move forward.”
Mr Sayed-Khaiyum explained the human costs, again quite correctly: “People … need to have decent living, sustain jobs, they need to have their children go to school … If the economy goes down there will be less jobs and there will be an inability to invest in infrastructure.”
While Mr Sayed-Khaiyum did not say “do as I say, not as I do” and his memory may be failing him, it is still good advice.
Economic impact
Indeed, economists have been pointing out Mr Sayed-Khaiyum’s message since 1987.
After independence in 1970, the Fiji economy was racing along (Graph 1, the top dotted line).
Then the first quiet coup happened in 1977 (large black dot on the graph) when the NFP won the elections, but the Governor-General appointed Ratu Sir Kamisese Mara as prime minister of a minority government.
After a successful motion of “no confidence” and fresh elections, the Alliance won and ruled Fiji for the next 10 years, also increasing military expenditure “just in case”.
The economy (solid black line on the graph) now stumbled along, well below the old trend indicated by the top dotted line.
(Note: The larger the gap between the dotted line and the solid line of actual growth, the larger is the lost national income, household incomes, and jobs.)
The “just in case” happened in 1987 when the NFP/FLP won the election.
Mr Rabuka and the military obliged with a coup and threw out the legal framework of the 1970 Constitution.
But now the military genie refused to go back into the bottle and Rabuka became an elected PM and further escalated spending on the military “just in case”.
The economy declined for a couple of years, but recovered to a moderate growth path (second dotted line) as Fiji’s business community gleefully realised that a military political leader would give them more favours than an accountable elected PM (a lesson remembered after the 2006 coup also).
“Just in case” happened again in 1999, when Mr Rabuka’s and Inoke Kubuabola’s SVT was decimated and Mr Chaudhry’s government elected, with the military genie doing another coup in 2000, led by shadowy figures still to be publicly identified.
Both Mr Bainimarama and interim PM Mr Qarase tried to throw out the “legal framework” of the 1997 Constitution, but Justice Anthony Gates threw a spanner in their works.
The economy took another battering but slowly recovered (third dotted line).
By now political instability simmered as Mr Qarase tried to rein in Mr Bainimarama, who did his 2006 coup, declared himself PM without any elections or help of a legal framework, although Mahendra Chaudhry was at hand.
This time, the economy stagnated for four years, with formal sector employment declining by about 3 per cent and real incomes declining by a large 30 per cent.
Following some diversions provided by John Samy’s People’s Charter, the legal framework reinforced by the Court of Appeal judgment was thrown out with the 1997 Constitution.
Following more constitutional diversions from Yash Ghai and his merry team, they, the peoples assembly, and Fiji’s legal were all dispensed with by Mr Bainimarama and Mr Sayed-Khaiyum who imposed their own constitution in 2013, giving themselves immunity.
Now they have rewarded Fiji people with a free public holiday to celebrate a constitution they had no hand in — a hand-out employers will be quietly gnashing their teeth over.
The economy has been growing strongly from 2012, but so far entirely because of massive increases in government expenditure on infrastructure and public debt.
If RBF growth projections are correct (another story), the GDP is now approaching the pre-2006 growth path (third dotted line) but Fiji has forever lost four years of economic growth, incomes and jobs (the gap between the dotted line and solid black line).
“Use the law”
and “condemn sedition”
Mr Sayed-Khaiyum’s advice to dissatisfied people in Ra and politicians in general is: “To believe in the legal framework … follow the proper channel … If the people of Fiji want to vote out a particular party from government they do that through the polls… and elections. … the people of Fiji understand that at the end of the day it is the Fijian people’s livelihoods at stake…”
But Mr Bainimarama and Mr Sayed-Khaiyum themselves did not contest the 2006 elections and “follow the proper legal process” to replace the Qarase government, as Mr Sayed-Khaiyum is advising today.
Mr Sayed-Khaiyum today lectures “Any responsible government or party needs to say that any destabilisation is not good for the country”.
But Ratu Mara’s Alliance did not condemn the coup in 1987, nor did Ratu Inoke Kubuabola’s SVT and Mr Qarase’s SDL condemn the coup in 2000, nor did Mahendra Chaudhry’s FLP condemn the coup in 2006, of which Mr Bainimarama’s FijiFirst party is a direct beneficiary.
Economists’ advice
is good advice
Mr Sayed-Khaiyum’s advice should be followed, whether he and his leader follow it themselves or not.
Graph 2 (from World Bank data) by comparing our economic performance (bottom line) with that of Mauritius (top line), shows clearly the long term costs of our political instability and military coups.
Mauritius is a small island nation just like Fiji, dependent on sugar and tourism, but much poorer in land and other resources, and half the people are kaidia.
Fiji has a military that costs taxpayers more than a hundred million dollars annually (what does that amount to in 10 years?), does coups now and then that cost Fiji billions of dollars, while Mauritius has no standing army and no coups.
Between 1976 and 2014, Fiji’s GDP has merely doubled while Mauritius has increased five times.
As Mr Sayed-Khaiyum says, any attempt to change the government by force will mean more political instability, loss of investor confidence, and loss of jobs and incomes, while poverty will increase.
Politicians who want to change the government should do the hard work and change people’s minds by the 2018 elections, as Mr Sayed-Khaiyum advises.
Unfortunately, it is much easier to do military coups, as all our former military commanders and Mr Sayed-Khaiyum himself, will probably testify.
Unfortunately it is also clear now that Mr Bainimarama and Mr Sayed-Khaiyum are going to use their parliamentary pliant majority to reject even reasonable proposals from the opposition parties, as they did with Tupou Draunidalo’s recommendation for a neutral parliamentary counsel. Do Mr Bainimarama and Mr Sayed-Khaiyum want to give the message that peaceful processes through parliament and dialogue will get the opposition nowhere?
How can opposition parties “do what Mr Sayed-Khaiyum says” when it amounts to pots telling kettles not to be black?
* The views expressed are the author’s and not of this newspaper.
