Search

Mitigating risks

AS we discussed last week, trade misinvoicing is increasingly being used as one of the most common means of shifting illicit funds offshore.

Statistics compiled by Global Financial Integrity (GFI) estimates that Fiji’s cumulative trade misinvoicing outflows from 2003-2012 was $US2136million ($F4638m) — averaging $US214m ($F464m) annually.

It peaked in 2008 reaching to an all-time high of $US391m ($F849m) and then gradually sliding down to $US87m ($F188m) in 2012. The combined sum is quite substantial for an economy of our size and cannot be ignored.

In terms of the breakdown by component import overinvoicing constitutes a major chunk of the outflows.

The challenge now is how to get this money back into the country.

Several measures have already been implemented by governments in a bid to track the black money parked abroad.

Fiji has recently extended the amnesty period for the declaration of foreign owned assets by locals.

India has also promulgated a similar legislation, which provides for a 90-day compliance window for foreign assets holders to declare undisclosed assets, pay a total of 60 per cent tax and penalty to escape imprisonment up to 10 years.

Similar approaches are being initiated by other countries for the repatriation of the money kept in foreign accounts by local businesses offering various incentives for voluntary disclosure.

However, we need to put in place more stringent and preventive measures to control the illicit outflows.

Customs constraints

In the past segment, we saw how manipulation of price of imports not only causes revenue loss but also creates a hostile trading environment for honest traders thus sending a negative signal to potential investors.

It is often said that criminals are always one step ahead of the law in terms of crafting innovative and sophisticated tactics to outwit the system. As they say (sarcastically), it’s the lame one who gets caught.

Because of resource constraints, most Customs administrations in developing countries are usually under-equipped and also lack skilled personnel with specialisation in the detection of highly complex valuation fraud.

Unfortunately, the emphasis on acceptance of transaction value under the WTO Agreement on Customs valuation does not make the task any easier for them to cope with the problems of value manipulation.

It is only in cases where there is an element of doubt as to the accuracy of the declared value that the onus shifts on to the importer to substantiate the veracity of the invoice price.

Changing non-compliant behaviour

As we have noted earlier, there are several reasons for those operating in the black economy. To a large extent public perception also plays a part in influencing the non-compliant behaviour.

Sometimes resistance is borne out of a rebellious attitude towards the tax regime emanating from perceived disparities such as those between corporate and personal tax and how taxpayers’ money is spent by governments.

Some strongly advocate the view that because businesses make profits they should be taxed more. Otherwise the inequality in the distribution of wealth will never be narrowed.

It is well known that some traders operate under a facade of conducting legitimate business to cover their illicit activities with the sole aim of making money by hook or by crook.

And there are those who may ask, “Why should I do the right thing when I know my competitors are cheating?”

Therefore, demonstrating the overall fairness and integrity of the tax system is extremely imperative to gain the trust of the taxpayers. Likewise, transparency in the manner any reward system is administered is equally important as well to allay any misconception of favouritism.

Minimising the risk

Researchers have acknowledged that the challenge of reducing the shadow economy and the potential revenue gain from doing so for developing countries cannot be underscored. A report prepared by Barrie Russell for the International Monetary Fund has recommended a range of practical measures that revenue agencies can apply towards minimising the risk of shadow economy. Some of those include:

* Simplification of tax laws and regulations and reduction of taxes on micro and small businesses;

* Rationalisation of the tax structure;

* Streamlining procedures towards reducing cost of compliance;

* Promoting a voluntary compliance culture through offering attractive incentives and assistance;

* Demonstrate a highly visible and credible detection and enforcement capacity to deal with non-compliance;

* Identify and address the underlying causes for non-compliance; and

* Special attention to be accorded to new businesses with the aim to prevent compliance issues from arising.

Below are some recommendations or suggestions, which if implemented, will assist in addressing the present gaps towards reinforcing the institutional capacity of the enforcement agencies with the identification, investigation and prosecution of illicit activities relating to black money.

1. Undertake more rigorous valuation scrutiny of export and imports transactions exempt from duty.

2. More efforts should be directed towards boosting the Customs enforcement by equipping and training officers.

3. Strengthen co-ordination and collaboration between various agencies in charge of tax, labour, immigration, trade, licensing, registration of companies, statistics and exchange control.

* Selwa Nandan is a former adviser for trade facilitation with Oceania Customs Organisation and a consultant on Customs and trade matters. For feedback, email: selwa.nandan@gmail.com.